The Book of Boba Fett, Chapter Three: The Streets of Mos Espa (3/5)

-

I was incredibly excited for this episode after the previous week and how wonderful it was. I was disappointed to say the least. After a 4.5/5 premiere and a 5/5 second episode, I had a lot of hope. Unfortunately, I can’t give this one more than a 3/5 and that is really pushing it for me. A major part of me wants to give it lower, so I feel as though I am being more than fair.

The acting was incredible as always, the present-day storyline was enjoyable. I think that it’s really special what Boba is doing for the people of Mos Espa. To me, him hiring the youth gang with the cool speeders rather than punishing them was doing better for the city than the water monger wanted. If they have work, they’re not going to get into trouble, and they’ll be more likely to be provided for, which was a real indictment of how we handle crime and punishment in our society because we don’t look out for each other. The people at the top simply want to punish those at the bottom for not having the resources that they do. The present-day plot was a heavier part of this episode, which was nice, I suppose, because it did add balance to what was happening. We got more of the Twins, some awesome Black Krrsantan moments, including a boss fight scene, which was amazing. We got a speeder chase which was fun, but could have been faster in my opinion, and all of that stuff makes me okay with giving it a 3/5 as opposed to a lower score. I would have liked to see Madam Garsa, but I suppose she can’t be in every episode, which is fine.

The part that really took away from this episode was the flashback part of the plot, and it took away from it in a major way. In the first two episodes, I was very excited about the Tusken plot. I loved getting to spend more time with them, getting to watch them be humanized, and just getting to watch their interactions with Boba. This episode really disappointed me in a major way with that plotline because I am tired of stories where marginalized characters get fridged. I hate it in such a way that it almost fully ruined the episode for me. It was a terrible way for this plot to be handled, and it felt like part of the point of it was that they ‘needed’ Boba to protect them and that without him, they can’t defend themselves. To have yet another group of Tuskens massacred offscreen like it’s Attack of the Clones all over again simply to impact the story of another character almost made me sick. Can we not have a story where Indigenous people aren’t subject to the trauma of being massacred? Please? Is that too much to ask? As a non-Indigenous person, I was angry at this choice that they made, and I cannot imagine how it must feel for Indigenous people who had to watch that without any warning. For all that I have seen people speaking about it, there is no experience I have that really comes close to this, even with the intersections of my own identity.

The main failure I think here is caused by the lack of diversity within the writing team for The Book of Boba Fett. Yes, this episode spoke to the stories of a lot of Indigenous people, with the coming home to find your community slaughtered, but it could have been handled in a completely different way, which could have been achieved by having an Indigenous person in the writing room. However, I do stand firm on my belief that the most important voices in this conversation are those of Indigenous people, which is why what I have said on the matter is all I will say. My opinions have been structured partially from listening to Indigenous people around me and their reactions, and I implore everyone to listen to the voices of those who are closer to the issue.

Honestly, if the main criticism a person has of this episode is the speeders, that is a person that I have no desire to listen to. Yes, it could have been faster or whatever, the VFX could have been done better, but there are more important issues with this episode and how science fiction and fantasy stories featuring the voices of marginalized people are told. Beyond what I have said above, there isn’t really much else I have to say about this episode.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Path of Vengeance by Cavan Scott (5/5) [CONTAINS SPOILERS]

-
Path of Vengeance by Cavan Scott is the second YA novel of Star Wars: The High Republic phase two. This novel encapsulates the events of the Battle of Jedha and the Battle of Dalna, with the Battle for the Path in between the two. These events have previously been seen through other perspectives in The Battle of Jedha by George Mann (audiobook), Cataclysm by Lydia Kang (adult novel), Quest for Planet X (middle grade novel) by Tessa Gratton, and The High Republic by Cavan Scott (comics). One of the biggest drawbacks from this book, through no fault of Scott or his co-writers in the initiative, is the fact that it does spoil the comics, as some have not come out yet due to delays. However, I find the story intriguing enough that knowing how it ends isn’t going to remove my enjoyment of the ending of the comics at all, this is just something that ought to be considered noteworthy. Path of Vengeance follows not only the Ro cousins that we met in Path of Deceit by Justina Ireland &
Read more

The Odyssey of Star Wars by Jack Mitchell (5/5)

-
Jack Mitchell’s The Odyssey of Star Wars is brilliant on a level that I cannot explain. I read it on the recommendation of a friend of mine, and I could not be happier that I did. I rated it five stars, and that is an honest as heck rating that I don’t see changing. One of my favourite things about these ‘retellings’ of Star Wars in the style of the classics is that there is so many themes that come from the classics that we see in Star Wars that prove how strong and important these classics are when examining modern media. I’m going to be honest, if someone tells me that The Odyssey of Star Wars isn’t canon, I will not care. Anything in this book, I will take it as canon because it all makes sense to me in how it flows. The parts where it adds new information, it all makes sense, and it doesn’t really require too much detail. I love that it adds the new information that we’ve gotten since the release of the original trilogy. There are things that allude to the prequels, Rebels , an
Read more

Introduction

-
 Hello! Welcome to my blog!  My name is Ash, I use she/they pronouns and I am 24 years old. I am currently a student of Creative Writing & Publishing at Sheridan College in Ontario, Canada. I have a lifelong passion for reading and writing, and talking about the things that I enjoy. This is my outlet for that.  Primarily, I will be sharing reviews from books that I have read (most of them Star Wars at this current time, as it is a passion of mine), and occasionally snippets of my own writing that I have done myself.  I am also a Founding Member of The Storyteller's Tavern, a TTRPG podcast and website that focuses on inclusion, diversity, and breaking down gatekeeping in the community.  Finally, feel free to follow me on social media. You can find me on Twitter and TikTok @ashofclanwren.  Thank you so much for visiting my blog, and I hope you enjoy my thoughts on what I've been reading.
Read more